Project 4. Which of the found items is most similar to the original?

In this customizable project, Tolokers compare images of shoes with the original image and decide which pair of images is most similar. To make a comparison in the project, add the results from the second project. To learn how, see Prepare and upload a TSV file with tasks.

  1. Create a project
  2. Create a pool
  3. Prepare and upload a TSV file with tasks
  4. Get the results

Create a project

To create a project, open Toloka for requesters.

In the interface:
  1. Choose a template:

    1. Click Create project.

    2. Select the Image comparison (Side-by-side) template.

  2. Provide general information:

    1. In the Name for Tolokers field, enter Which object is similar to the original one?.

    2. In the Description for Tolokers field, enter Decide which pair of shoes is most similar to the original shoes..

    3. Optionally add a Private comment.

    4. Save the changes.

  3. Edit the task interface in the editor you selected:

    Template Builder
    HTML/CSS/JS editor
    1. Use the ready-made code for this project with pre-configured validation, keyboard shortcuts, and task layout.

      The Toloker won't be able to submit the response until they:

      • Visit the online store.
      • Select one of the response options.
    2. Click Show specifications to see the input and output data fields.

      • Input data fields:

        • image — A link for uploading the image of the original product.
        • left_link — A link to the product in the online store for the left button.
        • right_link — A link to the product in the online store for the right button.
      • Output data field: result — string for saving the Toloker's response.

    1. In the Task Interface, delete the template code from the HTML block and paste the following code:

      <div class="header">
          <div class="left caption">
              {{button label="Go to site" href=uploaded_link_left size="L"}}
              <p class="url">{{uploaded_link_left}}</p>
          </div>
          <div class="right caption">
              <p class="url">{{uploaded_link_right}}</p>
              {{button label="Go to site" href=uploaded_link_right  size="L"}}
          </div>
      </div>
      
      {{img src=image}}
      
      <div class="content clearfix">
          <div class="left page">
              {{iframe src=uploaded_link_left width="100%" height="700px" real-size=true screenshot=true}}
          </div>
          <div class="right page">
              {{iframe src=uploaded_link_right width="100%" height="700px" real-size=true screenshot=true}}
          </div>
      </div>
      
      <div class="footer">
          {{field type="radio" name="result" label="Left image is better" value="result_left" hotkey="1"}}
          {{field type="radio" name="result" label="Right image is better" value="result_right" hotkey="2"}}
      </div>
      Copied to clipboard
    2. In the js block, edit the code by adding the following lines before OnRender.
      Attention.

      Don't remove the existing code.

      getTemplateData: function() {
              var data = TolokaHandlebarsTask.prototype.getTemplateData.apply(this, arguments),
              input = this.getTask().input_values;
              var left_link = input.left_link;
              var right_link = input.right_link;
              var uploaded_link_left = '',
                  uploaded_link_right = ''
              if (Math.floor(Math.random() * 2)) {
                  uploaded_link_left = left_link
                  uploaded_link_right = right_link
              } else {
                  uploaded_link_left = right_link
                  uploaded_link_right = left_link
              }
        data.uploaded_link_left = uploaded_link_left;
              data.uploaded_link_right = uploaded_link_right;
              data.result_left = uploaded_link_left;
              data.result_right = uploaded_link_right;
      
              return data;
      
          },
      Copied to clipboard
    3. In the css block, insert the following code that is responsible for setting the proportional image size:

      .task {
        display: block;
        text-align:center;
      }
      
      .header {
        overflow: hidden;
        background-color: #FFCC00;
      }
      
      .caption {
        width: 50%;
      }
      
      .url {
        white-space: nowrap;
        overflow: hidden;
        text-overflow: ellipsis;
      
        max-width: calc(100% - 182px);
      
        display: inline-block;
        vertical-align: bottom;
      }
      
      .button {
        margin: 10px;
        max-width: 182px;
      }
      
      .button__label {
        white-space: nowrap;
        overflow: hidden;
        text-overflow: ellipsis;
        max-width: 150px;
      }
      
      .content {
        margin: 10px 0;
      }
      
      .page {
        display: inline-block;
        width: 50%;
      }
      
      .left {
        float: left;
        text-align: left;
      }
      
      .right {
        float: right;
        text-align: right;
      }
      
      .clearfix {
        overflow: hidden;
        width: 100%;
      }
      Copied to clipboard
    4. Edit the input and output data in the Data specification block.

      1. Click to switch graphic mode to JSON format.

      2. In the Input data field, enter:

        {
          "image": {
            "type": "url",
            "hidden": false,
            "required": true
          },
          "left_link": {
            "type": "url",
            "hidden": false,
            "required": true
          },
          "right_link": {
            "type": "url",
            "hidden": false,
            "required": true
          }
        }
        Copied to clipboard
      3. In the Output data field, enter:

        {
          "result": {
            "type": "url",
            "hidden": false,
            "required": true
          }
        }
        Copied to clipboard

        Learn more about the Specification parameters in Input and output data.

      4. Click to see the Toloker's view of the task.

        Note. The project preview shows one task with standard data. You can define the number of tasks to show on the page later.
        1. In the window that opens, check if the task options work correctly. In the lower-right corner, click Submit.

        2. Exit preview mode.

          In the lower-left corner, click Exit. If there were errors when testing, check the code blocks that you entered.

  4. Save the changes.

  5. In Instructions for Tolokers, enter the instructions.

    1. Instructions:
      Look at 2 pictures with different shoes and decide which pair of shoes looks most similar to the original pair. 
      Rely on your own sense of style, but also remember that the shoes look alike if 
      they are the same color, fabric, length, and style.
      Copied to clipboard
    2. Save the changes.

  6. To go back to the Projects page, click Finish editing.

Learn more about working with the project in the Customizable project section.

Create a pool

To create a pool:

  1. Open the page of the project titled Which shoes look more alike.

  2. Click the Add pool button.

  3. Specify the pool name.

  4. (optional) Add a Private comment. This information is available only to you.

  5. Filter Tolokers in the Tolokers section of the Audience block.

    1. Click Add filter.

    2. Find the Toloker profile block in the list and choose the Languages skill.

    3. In the ? field specify =.

    4. Add another filter. Click Add filter.

    5. Find the Skills block in the list and click Choose your skill.

    6. In the Skills field, select Found_shoes.

    7. In the ? field specify =.

    8. Leave the Absent field empty.

    Tasks in pools will automatically be available in the web version of Toloka and the mobile app. If you want to change the default settings and limit the visibility of the task for any of the versions, add the Client filter and select the desired value: Toloka web version or Toloka for mobile.

  6. (optional) In the Speed/quality balance section, specify the desired quality level. Improving quality may reduce the speed of task completion because the pool will be available to fewer Tolokers. Learn more in the Speed/quality balance section.

  7. Enter 0.01 in the Price per task suite field in the Price block.

  8. In the Quality control block, specify quality control settings for the pool:

    1. Click Add a quality control rule.

    2. Find the Rules block in the list and choose Fast responses.

    3. Set a rule for fast responses: if the number of fast responses is more than 3, then restrict the Toloker's access to the project for 10 days. Specify Fast responses as the reason for ban.

    Learn more in Quality control.

  9. Enter 10 in the The number of Tolokers to complete each task field in the Task overlap section.

  10. In the Additional settings block:

    1. Enter 300 in the Time per task suite field.

    2. Turn on the Keep task order option.

  11. Click Create a pool.

Prepare and upload a TSV file with tasks

  1. Download the TSV file received in the third project.

  2. Create pairs for each input image so that you can compare the two found images with the original one and decide which one is more similar.

    You can create pairs manually using a text editor or automatically, like using Python or Jupyter Lab.

    As an example, you can use our results https://tlk.s3.yandex.net/wsdm2020/SbS_Toloka_prep&aggr_data.ipynb.

  3. Open the Which item is more similar? pool.

  4. Click Upload. In the window that opens, configure the file upload settings.

  5. Choose Set manually.

  6. In the Tasks per suite field, specify1. You can experiment with the number of tasks per suite.

  7. Click Upload.

  8. In the window that opens, choose the TSV file with tasks to upload and click Open.

  9. Click to start the pool.

    Attention.

    The tasks will be completed by real Tolokers in Toloka. Recheck your project setup before you start the pool.

Get the results

To get the results:

  1. Click Download results.

    1. In the Status block, only leave the Accepted option enabled.

    2. In the Fields block, leave the link, response ID, and Toloker ID options enabled.

  2. Disable the Separate assignments with empty row option.

  3. Try to use the Bradley-Terry model based on the results. As an example, you can use our https://tlk.s3.yandex.net/wsdm2020/SbS_Toloka_prep&aggr_data.ipynbresults.